If Scoundrel/Dual Wielding actually worked, people would put points into it now and it clearly doesn't. Not just because Warfare is better, but because the other two options suck until Warfare is maxed. Rogues do pathetic damage without Warfare and neither Warriors or Rogues start doing really high damage until the later half of Act 2 when the game is over half finished.
I'm not agree with this statement. Dual wielding /scoundrel actually works. I'm playing that build on tactician act 3 and just melt almost every enemies.
I dont see all this problems with warfare, honestly. I mean, i'm not using warfare too much, and do just fine.
My main chara is a necrowarrior with two handed/scoundrel, and my companion is sebille rogue with dual wield/scoundrel. Both of them do insane damage, and i put just 3-4 points in warfare just to use some skills.