I'd love crafting as a civil skill. Just one would do - no need for separate crafting/blacksmithing and certainly not multiple ones.
Crafting was one of my favorite things in the last game - both as a way to make money (which you needed to sometimes especially at the start) and if you invested the points in it (as opposed to another civil skill) a way to get high quality weapons, add resistances to armour etc. It was an alternative to investing in stealing or luck.
Here it is pointless - nothing you can craft is any good so you collect all these sticks and stones for nothing. Its a shame as all the pre-requisites (ingredients, recipes) are there just the end result is underwhelming.
If there was a crafting civil skill then quality could be based on that without unbalancing game as you would have had to invest in that rather than some other way of getting items.
