Well, while it is a little inconsistent, it's not like a person can't change his mind, especially if they are really torn on the issue in the first place :P
That said, my problem with Gareth in Act 3 was more of a thing where I felt I really wanted Ifan to kill the asshat, so it felt a little hypocritical persuading Gareth to let go, and then telling Ifan to go ahead and do his worst :P.
Last edited by rheia; 19/10/17 08:59 AM.