And people call Starwars an rpg....its nothing but trash and garbage! The only true RPG's are magic and sword fighting in a cool medieval fantasy world!!
*quickly ducks for cover underneath his carefuly constructed popcan stronghold as the chaos rages across the landscape*
I know you're just baiting people, but I'll play the devil's advocate: so... everything that is set in a medieval fantasy world, with swordsplay and magic, a RPG, right? What about, say, Baldur's Gate: Dark Alliance, a game that's clearly labeled as a beat-em-up? What about Enclave, another beat-em-up (but on PC)? And the Warcraft games -- which, prior to WCIII, don't even have the RPG elements of XP and leveling up? What 'bout, say, Age of Empire?