Originally Posted by miaasma

hoping for...? that your 2000th post will cause larian to experience some sort of revelation and completely overhaul their game? i would think it is incredibly obvious by now that you have a fundamental problem with the game and that it just isn't what you had hoped it would be. that's unfortunate and i'm sorry you can't enjoy this game the way you wanted to, but constantly berating it like this only serves to turn every thread into some woefest about what could have been


To be fair, if it is, you would be one of the reason this thread is a "woefest".
The whole conversation around subjective and objective is kind of a moot point, at this point you can argue that everything is subjective.
To me the post of Luckmann was pretty much on point to me with a list of constructed arguments as why the game has some flaws. It could still be enjoyable, and people could still praise it very much (they do).
But saying "if you don't like the game just don't play it and leave" is a little idiotic.
I do too think the game has flaws, the same pretty much than those addressed by Luckmann (arguments that are not really being discussed which was the point of it all), and although I really enjoyed playing the first one, I did not really enjoyed playing the second one. And why are we bothering? To this point because we thought that some of it could be changed for the better, and now because some of us feel the points made here are still valid and could be read by Larian and taken into account for possibly future games...

Shouting through the megaphone "like it or leave it" does not help at all. But maybe the point listed by Luckmann are actually qualities that we should celebrate, if so, let's hear about it.