Quick update from me.

I made a quick rush, and it worked !

Here are the dialogues I triggered:


- After talking to a guard next to a zapper -> 'Doomsday device'? 'Source sapphire'? Why don't we keep along this 'poisonous path' and carry on with our 'insidious investigation.' Meanwhile, Madora, keep the crackpot commentary to yourself.

- After leaving the homestead for the first time -> If what Zixzax says is true and we really are affecting the tapestry of time, I certainly want to know more!

- Talk to Thelyron about the healing stone -> Given your penchant for spotting Source in Cyseal's every harmless cranny, such an accusation holds little weight.

- Decide to spare the Charmed Orc -> Does the thought of interbreeding sicken you so? For my part, the union itself is hardly a problem, and I'd claim that anyone opposed to the couple on those grounds is small-minded indeed.

- After talking to Lawrence -> "Your paranoia becomes increasingly tiresome by the day Madora"

- After hearing Grutilda or Leonard talking about Norok -> Be patient; We can't blow our cover over a personal vendetta. (DOES NOT COUNT FOR THE FIVE).

I made many tests.
I confirm the right answer for Lawrence is "Your paranoia becomes increasingly tiresome by the day Madora", so the one in the guide is wrong.

And that this dialogue:
- After hearing Grutilda or Leonard talking about Norok -> Be patient; We can't blow our cover over a personal vendetta.

Does not count.
Sure picking the other options "we will make Norok pay" might makes you fail the achievement.
But skipping entirely this dialogue has no impact, and the right answer does not count towards the achievement.
You need 5 more.

Also I can confirm you don't need Madora in your party the whole time.
I only picked her for the dialogues and removed her immediatly.
I red you need to have her in the phantom forest the whole time.
This is wrong, you only need her for the dialogues, and obviously, to resolve the quest.

And don't forget about the forgiving trait on both characters (not sure)
Maybe you need compassionate or others.


Well not such a quick update...