That happens at a specific point. If a character was an NPC at the point you did that, and a player took control over them after that, then no, they don't get to see that event because it has already been finished. You would need to load a game from before that point and have the extra party member take over there.
Would it be easier/weirder if the request was a way to create a Avatar Character I can inject into a save file?
So I think then we are hitting some sort of bug because he was in control of the character when all of the other characters were teleported into the instance. (where we each spoke to our gods and they warned us of the others) He was just sat there in town while we completed that instance.
That's flat-out impossible. Characters cannot be separated from save files.
Ok good to know. I wasnt sure if they were just a collection of data tied to some Character ID somehow.
