Can we stop moving goalposts here?

The argument at hand was that this looks less "dark" and "gritty" than Baldurs Gate 1 and 2.
So you gotta make THAT comparison.

Vometia: thats because Witcher shows a world based off medieval poland, pretty grim place.
Baldurs Gate meanwhile shows Faerun which is the magical realm of a hippie writer. Baldurs Gate 2s idyllic medieval maedows didnt look any less idyllic than baldurs gate 3s.

AnonySImon wheres the grime and the blood in Baldurs Gate 2?
The character portraits look pretty clean, besides scars on the edgy dwarf.

You are moving the goalposts, Truth is, dynamic dirt and grime is not neccesarily easy to do. Dynamic blood splatters are the only thing i know any RPGs pulling off, and since nobody else did it yet, (at least not any RPGs, uncharted is not an RPG) you cant realy expect this game to do it can you now?