Originally Posted by Sordak
If they were to rename the game (which they wont, and cannot), would you shut up?
no.


Of course people would no longer complain. Do you think anybody cares if Larian makes a game? Of course they don't. What they care about is that Larian is co-opting another game series to make a clone of their DOS series, and are marketing their D&D DOS formula game as something that it isn't - which is a Baldur's Gate series game.

If Larian called their game anything that wasn't pretending to be Baldur's Gate 3, nobody would complain.

Quote

You wouldnt. youd mvoe the goalpost yet again.

At firs tit was "it was gonna have the divinity ruleset" no it doesnt.
then it was "it will have too much humor and wont be grimdark" cue the trailer
now its "we dont like the name"


You should put at least some thought into your post. The former two criticisms, about the ruleset (I haven't seen that criticism and I'm guessing that you haven't, either and are just BSing) and the type of humour, only apply because Larian are claiming it to be Baldur's Gate 3. If Larian weren't claiming it to be a part of the original Baldur's Gate PC series then there'd be no measurement by which to say it should or shouldn't have a particular ruleset or a certain style of humour.

Quit making nonsense up out of thin air to pretend that you have an argument when you have none.