They want Baldur's gate 1 & 2 Remastered.

They want the same combat.
They want the same, if updated, graphics.
They want the same story.

They literally are arguing against Baulder's Gate 3 because they want it to be the same game they played 20 years ago. They are literally saying 'it has to be more like BG 1& 2!' and 'It's not a real BG without RTwP!' and 'It does not LOOK like BG' (which is 20 years old, mind you, and this game is still in pre-alpha, but sure; bash placeholder graphics), and '100 years later? That's not a sequel!'.

You guys won't want a sequel; you want the first two games remastered. That's why you're so angry at Larian & BG3.