They want Baldur's gate 1 & 2 Remastered.
They want the same combat.
They want the same, if updated, graphics.
They want the same story.
They literally are arguing against Baulder's Gate 3 because they want it to be the same game they played 20 years ago. They are literally saying 'it has to be more like BG 1& 2!' and 'It's not a real BG without RTwP!' and 'It does not LOOK like BG' (which is 20 years old, mind you, and this game is still in pre-alpha, but sure; bash placeholder graphics), and '100 years later? That's not a sequel!'.
You guys won't want a sequel; you want the first two games remastered. That's why you're so angry at Larian & BG3.
Oh man, I wish you wouldn't have made this post

Not that I don't agree with you or anything, but I feel you are taking your feeling from other posts over here and it's not going to be healthy.
I'm not saying it to pick a fight. After 4 days of seeing people complain about every aspect of BG3, the overarching theme is that those people seem to want a remaster, not a sequel.
I just feel bad that the crew at Larian has to deal with this BS. They are making a great sequel, and yet half the fanbase is frothing at the mouth that it's not 'real' and the other half is frothing back at the first half.
(And yes, I'm in that second camp)
It's a civil-bloody-war!