yeah only simple and quick only applies to some classes.
ive said it before in this thread, even with Tome of battle, the utiltiy of fighters werent even near that of casters.

Anyone CAN play a Champion fighter if they want.
but give me damn combat options.

Abstracting melee ocmbat even MORE to the point where your only option is "Basic attack "nad anyhting beyond that beeing highly situational is boring.

What makes it boring is that this way, theres only one reason to play a fighter, and thats if you are new at the game.
but quite frankly, DnD is about fantasy.
And the fantasy of beeing a Scrawny wizard doesnt appeal to me.