"we are starting out in a temple of Selune and traveling with priest of Shar. Great!"
Yea...The priest of Shar has lots of enemies, and she seems a mess anyway..Oh and the Trickery Domain is sub-par, so she can sod off. (Evil and confused)
A vampire who may try to give me a hickey...no thank-you. (Evil)
A warlock who regrets his own decisions....sigh...just say no to self loathing drama...crossed his own line for power. (Evil and confused)
A Wizard who blows up his own peeps...naw...more drama. (Neutral and unreliable)
A Githyanki who doesn't hate herself or whine, but instead steps up to adversity...she's a winner! (Displays good qualities...although her race is traditionally or perhaps situationaly lawful evil)
I am hoping for some good archetypes when they add in the remaining npc choices...otherwise its hirelings and the Gith.
See...they don't need tags. Evil is as evil does.