Sorry I don't buy this. First of all, I'm a little tired of the trope of the evil characters can be "redeemed", and it's the job, nay the obligation, of the good characters to spend their life redeeming all the evil characters. And secondly, what happens in the meantime, before they're redeemed? From the first gameplay video, if my PC saw Astarian sucking the blood of another of my companions in the middle of the night, I don't care what the excuses may be, Astarian is immediately getting staked. Similarly, she can have all the crises of faith she wants, but if Shadowheart does anything, I mean even the smallest thing, that is in the nature of Shar while in my party (Shar being incredibly, horribly evil), she's dead. And as such, I really don't want that to be the nature of the relationship between me and my party companions. I know many people nowadays insist that no one is truly good or evil and everyone is just the same shade of grey, but that's all just hogwash to me.
Agree that is also a legit path if you want to go that route. Hopefully we won’t end up in camp alone
