Originally Posted by Sordak
what?
you still gotta convince people the game is shit , i dont have to prove anyhting, if i lik ethe game ill get it

That's fine. And I also don't have to prove anything with respect to my personal take on the game.

My point is that for months now people have been telling critics like me that we can't criticize the game because it isn't out yet. And I'm simply saying that even after the game is released, these people will find some excuse to continue to tell me I can't criticize the game.
Originally Posted by neongreg
You can criticize all you want, but it doesn't make sense to say it's the same as dos2 cause it's turn based. Cause by that logic, knights of the old republic is just a baldurs gate rip off. I mean they're both RTwP.

In general I would agree. But in this case the context matters. And the context is a comparison of BG3 to BG2 versus D:OS2. And in that very limited and specific context, saying the combat system is more like D:OS2 than like BG2 is quite accurate.