I've only played Gothic 3 (well, and "that one" that came after). Wonderful game for its complexity, number of side-quests, atmosphere, scale and everything else; even though it started off in the middle of a battle where you could get pwned, which set the scene for about the first quarter of the game, and had bugs and terrible voice acting. It was still awesome. But how come there were only about three women in the entire game? It gave it a slightly odd vibe.