I would be fine with it being automatic since attacking twice (main hand/offhand) is done automatically. I would just ask that they apply it to crits automatically.

The only thing that could hold them back is player choice when they multiclass. Consider this: Fighter 2/Rogue X who has Action Surge. What if I, as a player crit fishing, don't get it on my first set of attacks, so I use Action Surge to see if I can get it on the second set of attacks? I wouldn't be able to do this because the game would have used my sneak attack during the first set of attacks.

Last edited by dreambled; 08/10/20 02:39 AM.