Originally Posted by WarChiefZeke
Originally Posted by Malkie
Originally Posted by WarChiefZeke
Yeah WoTC is, honestly, a pretty bad company that doesn't really understand why DnD fans like DnD in the first place. That's why that made 4th and 5th editions in the first place.



3.5 > AD&D > 5 > 4



3.5 was the pinnacle of customization. The worldbuilding of 2e was unmatched. 4th and 5th have the virtues of being casul and PnP-newbie-friendly at the expense of the good aspects of the previous editions.



Planescape is still my favourite setting. Mechanics though 3.5 is by far the best, at least 5 attempted to reintroduce some of the 3.5 stuff even if it is massively simplified..... 4 was just woeful in every way. Although I have to admit, some aspects of 3.5 were needlessly fluffed up and convoluted.

Last edited by Malkie; 09/10/20 12:31 AM.