I'm against this "commit after act 1" thing simply because we don't have any control over the character's class choices. Shadowheart is a terrible character, and should not be a cleric. She should be the warlock, and Wyll should be a paladin or cleric. But anyway, we have no control over the character's classes. they're all pre-determined. In divinity 2 we could turn the characters into any class we wanted. If we're going to have to "commit" to characters, then give us this same freedom.
However, I am against this "commitment" idea all together as well. just keep everyone bloody alive, Larian... it's so cheap to make us have to stick to 4 forever.
