Larian Studios Forums Baldur's Gate III Baldur's Gate III - Suggestions & Feedback Didn't Sell Astarion Out - No Approval?

Seems a bit of a missed opportunity.
I basically confessed to our vampire companion that we know his secret, encountered someone that was hunting him and DIDN'T SELL HIM OUT - and yet, no approval gain at all...?

You get approval if you go through the conversation and choose to attack when Astarion indicates you should. If you didn't kill the guy then he's still a threat to Astarion so, no approval.

Astarion wants to kill the dude, not leave him be.

Just tried to take Astarion along to go through the conversation and have let him kill the hunter without my interference and then another time I attacked the hunter after Astarion got nervous with no feedback or approval change... is it too late to get approval now or something?