I think instead of fighting pro or contra dice rolls, it should like all things be an OPTION, just like difficulty settings, this way player who wish to experience a 1-try-live-with-it can still enjoy their experience, and also people who want to play for the story/plot and create a specific character personality/story should have the option to disable the dice or roll only above 15. None of these play styles are 'superior' so gatekeeping it helps nobody it just makes some people's egos inflate by making their style feel like the correct/superior one. Having it be an option would satisfy both players who want a challenge and enjoy the playstyle of classic D&D, and it would also help people who want specific outcomes and do not have dozens of hours to replay/reload until they achieved the desired result. I have tried both ways, and if you want specific results expect to spend 60-70% of your game reloading and dice-rolling, which gets tiring and annoying after 1-2 hours. So again, I believe they should consider simply adding it to the options menu, such as a game difficulty and under a dice difficulty (easy - above 15; medium - above 8; hard - randomized/normal) or have an option to enable/disable it.
