For the most part I agree with OP, but I dont get this "poor rogue" thing. Maybe I do something wrong, but in my games rogue is always powerhouse of the team damage-wise. Dual wielding rogue with 2 +1 short swords hits like a truck with basically 4 attacks every round (3 if i need to move a lot). So why exactly is rogue nerfed in your opinion? Is he some kind of god in paper 5 ed?