You are drowned in nostalgia and can't see the facts. If you wrote this with comments like i don't like / I don't understand it could have been understandable. You cannot say this is not baldur's gate. It is BG3 btw.

If larian to release a game with mechanics from 22 years ago, (yeah beamdog EE are just re-releases ) no one , even the hardcore "real time with pause mob with pitchforks" wouldn't like it.

  • Quote
    1. ) The game takes place 100 years after the events of Baldurs gate 2. (after all this time you have forgotten all the spells you had in baldurs gate 2 and now start at level 1 and your max level is going to be 10 ?
    You are not the same character, if you even played and finished BGII you would have known YOU CANNOT be the same character because either it becomes a GOD, gets old, or just too powerful
  • Quote
    2.) The rules have changed, now wizards can cast divine spells
    Wizards should not learn all spells, i agree on this.
  • Quote
    The party suddenly reduced from 6 to 4 man in both games bg1 and 2 and even the dragonspear which came out just recently
    It's by the book, Most encounters and games balanced around 4 people. Dragonspear is released at 2016 but still uses the 2nd Edition Advanced Dungeons And Dragons system that first games use 20 years ago and BEAMDOG had a limited agreement on engine so they could not change anything fundemental.
  • Quote
    You cant roll your stats in the beggining of the game, its also one of the signature things of the baldurs gate
    Again, it's about DND Rules, infinite dice rolling removed for balance. It's not a signature thing of Baldur's Gate, you only played Baldur's gate with this feature. Temple of elemental evil also had this for instance.
  • Quote
    If i climb on a cliff my spells suddenly follow the gravity rules and for some unknown fkn reason start to miss!!! Low chance of landing a spell on a person above you and higher chance to land hit on a person below. This is not baldurs gate.
    Larian is the DM. They added a variant rule of sight and height to give advantage/disadvantage. Advantage / disadvantage again is a mechanic from 5e dnd. A DM can give it if it sees fit. Read *> 5eTools
  • Quote
    JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP JUMP,
    Jump is overused, disangage should be fixed and jump can be related to athletics. I belive Larian making lots of stuff quick action, made combat closer to Pathfinder 2.0 and made it more variant (3 actions to do any and all stuff: move attack drink pot jump etc way better than dnd action - bonus action - reaction stuff.) Pathfinder 2.0 is another system with much more detail.
  • Quote
    roll dice roll dice roll dice
    In DnD we roll the dice. If you want to convince people , play a charisma based character.
  • Quote
    There is no Minsc and boo, im not attracted to characters,
    Well this is possibly the worst part of your "criticism i guess. Minsc and Boo are probably dead. Characters are well-written and have much more depth than most. Anyone waking up with a tadpole would be angry against all. If you use shadowheart's blessing on Astarion you can do some weird shit. She's a trickery cleric, maybe evil but, well if you are going to execute her on first occasion without even giving her a chance or understanding , it seems you are evil too, seems you are a good fit. All of this is just too personal and one dimensional.
  • Quote
    i heard from the code of the game that you plan on making characters be any class
    Beamdog added this feature on EE and it was liked. I guess you did not realized? It is there because with new difficulty options or for people who already finished game, trying different class /party combinations was a blessing.
  • Quote
    No day and night cycle, sucks..
    Agreed.
  • Quote
    Loot.. When you kill a flaming fist they must drop plate armor, and absolutely awesome HELM,
    You dont' like evil cleric but you kill Flaming Fist soldiers for their HELM? wow. You should look into yourself so you won't became a monster while fighting monsters. Loot is fine in my opinion.
  • Quote
    None of baldurs gate had turn based combat, they wont change it at all but like Fextralife on youtube said, when you fight a LOT of enemies at once, this fight take like 40 minutes.. and it sucks.. they will never change it but its another reason on the list that indicates this game is far from baldurs gate. And dont forget im not talking about DND in general im talking exactly about B A L D U R S GATE, the idea of using famous name to rework existing engine and make new stories was great, and helps their advertising model, look how many people were hyped for this even STEAM servers were overloaded but goddamn it people if you can make this game more like baldurs gate and less like divinity please do so...


    5edition is turn based. Not this shit again, ok. 5e is turn based, real time with pause breaks initiative and class balance, most skills and spells became useless. It is just nostalgia talking. Heroes 6 is better than 3. Wake up.




He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And when you gaze long into an abyss the abyss also gazes into you.

AMD Ryzen 7700X, 64GB Ram, Rtx 3080 12GB, lg-34GK950F-B,Logitech Z906 Thx.