... if it doesn't work in the game, then critique it in those terms. ...
It doesn't work in the game hence why we criticise it.
Those (gameplay-based) criticisms are not the criticisms on which I was focusing in this post. Many people in the forums are in the habit of criticising change from 5e rules as if that was a problem in an of itself ("Fun is relative term. People are here for the DnD 5e rules not some bastardisation of it." - quite a few posts like this (real) quote around the forums.)
Last edited by Vynticator; 19/10/2007:41 AM. Reason: closed the brackets