I really don't get why BG3 writing is considered bad by you guys. Immersion breaking artificial mechanics may be bad scripting where you took an action but no one changes in accordance to that. Sure those things should be fleshed out, but the characters themselves are great to me (again this is my subjectivity against yours, so we most likely will not agree because there are not objective points to discuss other than our feelings. Pretty pointless huh?).
Short version? It's full of contrivances, conveniences, is sidestepping/misrepresenting established lore, and feels all in all too skittish, sensationalistic, and juvenile.
