ATTACK ROLLS:
3+7+6+4+3+8+3+8+6+5+3+5+2+9+8+6+8+7+5+1+17+4+8+7+1+2+9+8+1+1+5+6+4+8+15+6+7+5+2+6+17+19+4+10+1+4+1+3+5+9 = 302/50 = 6.04.
This actually looks worse than just attacking with disadvantage, the latter would give you 7.175 on average. However, the sample size might be too small for any reliable assessment, I suspect.
Personally, I also have some questions regarding the game's RNG. For example, a suspiciously high percentage of Crits landed by my party happens with targets having 5 or less HP remaining, which makes them sort of redundant. Scoring a Crit on an unharmed enemy, however, even with advantage? Good luck with that. So far, I've seen only 2 such outcomes, one per playthrough, when party's rogue one-shot a phase spider with sneak attack from shadows while on higher ground.
