+2
I didn't know about either of these scenes and I never would have. I imagine 95+% of players will recruit every companion they see, including on subsequent playthroughs, so it's not like you can really use the "different playthroughs" justification for this.

What if you don't have Astarion or Lae'zel for the first scenario? Does a scene with Shadowheart, Wyll, and/or Gale play?