Interesting to read everyones replies
Question 1 it seems to be 50/50 atm.
Question 2 has 4 anwsers for yes, 3 for no.
Question 3 5 for yes, 3 for no.
Question 4 has 5 for yes and 3 for no.
Question 5 has 2 for yes and 7 for no.
And question 6 has 2 for yes and 7 for no.
Anwsers which did not give a clear yes or no I dident count.
@robertthebard comparing advantage or disadvantage to a flat bonus isent really accurate though. A bonus of +5 wont do anything to counter a roll of 1. Only advantage gives you a chance to avoid it because you roll 2 die and pick the highest. Mind you rolling 1's is only an issue if critical misses have further effects then just missing. Which they dont seem to have atm. I havent seen anyone drop a weapon, break a bowstring or hit a friendly for example...
Disadvantage and advantage also nulify eachother and you generally cant counteract bonuses to hit outside if raising that ac beforehand.
Standing on high ground shouldnt counteract the fact that you cant see your enemy to name an example. Its just kind of silly...
In the same vein attacking someone who is on a elevated position doesent warrant disadvantage. Elevation might make it a tiny bit harder for a ranged combatant to hit, but that shouldnt be 'im literally blind atm' hard.
In my opinion ofcourse
