Honestly I consider "professional" reviewers to be in the same league as the average joe over on steam. It's all personal opinions and maybe one of them will align with yours but they're not any more reliable than anyone else.
Fair enough. But the D:OS2 fans swore by all those 10/10 pro reviews that D:OS2 received for why that game was the best game ever made blah blah blah. So, live by the sword, die by the sword?
