I like this Shar theory (of her "helping" the party). I had a similar theory, as her being against the Absolute is the only reasons I can see her going after
the weapon the Absolute wants. There are indication in the game files that a dead sharran cleric should be on the Nautiloid in the tutorial (dialogue related to it is still in temporary stage) and that would explain why Shadowheart was in a special pod, she wasn't picked up randomly. The Sharrans might have corrupted the tadpoles before you got them too.

But at the same time, there are indications that the BG Coven sent people in that mission to get all of them killed, but I'm starting to think that the BG Shar Coven was compromised by Absolute moles at the same time...


Originally Posted by Rhobar121
Originally Posted by ash elemental
Shar is powerful enough to weave a shadow shield strong enough to shield you even from a psionic pseudodeity.


From some dialogue it seems that the tadpole is powerful enough to resist Shar's power. So I rather doubt that this is her work.



That dialogue could be conditional to using the tadpole.

And it's not exactly resisting Shar's power, it's resisting the Nightsong's soul sucking kiss. Kiss that might also be conditional. If Shar is responsible for shielding the tadpole, then she would want you dead if you used it as well.