Larian Studios Forums Baldur's Gate III Baldur's Gate III - Suggestions & Feedback [Feedback] Dialogue is VERY Limiting

Let me expand on Mayrina. Yes, you can tell her that her brothers are dead before but if you kill the hag first you suddenly become mute to the words "the hag killed your brothers", Why?
People have a defense mechanism, this is why most of the time we don't want to admit we are wrong.
A normal person will always defend themselves when they are being blamed for something. The NPCs do that well most of the time. The PC however doesn't.
It's as if you're roleplaying a robot instead of a real person.

Considering we are allowed to be given a choice about our character's stats, class and even origin. It feels like we are only allowed to play the dumb character when it comes to dialogue, especially when talking or having arguments with major NPCs.