Originally Posted by Firesnakearies
Originally Posted by Leuenherz


For this specific example, however, it should be pointed out that backstab is apparently only intended for light weapons. It only works with heavier options because the system is not currently fully implemented in EA. The system is still bad, however, and this difference in effect on weapon types only adds further balance issues.



Do you mean Sneak Attack, the Rogue ability? Because yeah, that is supposed to be used only with a finesse or ranged weapon. But what Larian calls "backstab" is just a rear attack with advantage, which is allowed under the optional Facing rule in the DMG, and that has no weapon restrictions.



No, I'm specifically talking about backstab. I am well aware of what Sneak Attack is and how it works.

I recall the eventual light weapon restriction being mentioned in the that giant thread that calls for removal of advantage for height and backstab. To be fair, though, the poster did not provide a source, so that may prove incorrect in the end.

However, whether it's a partial implementation of the optional facing rule from the DMG (which no DM worth their salt would use) or an adaptation of their own handling of their equivalent to light weapons is irrelevant in the end.

The fact remains that it is bad for the balance of the game.

Last edited by Leuenherz; 22/11/20 02:46 PM.