Originally Posted by Dexai
Volo is, if I remember correctly, one of first original characters created back when TSR adopted the Forgotten Realms as an official setting back in... Middle of the 80's I believe? I remember he wasn't actually created by Ed Greenwood but one of the TSR . But regardless he is one of the most iconic mascot characters for the setting.

The bard sidekick (comedic or serious) archetype is itself a very common character in writing. Accusing characters of the same archetype for being plagiarized just because some new hip work also features that archetype is foolish and only showcases how ignorant you are about the greater world and history of literature that makes up the foundation of our cultural heritage.

In short, it's like accusing a hypothetical new Blade adaption of being a rip-off of Twilight because they both feature vampires (despite both deriving vampire tropes from even older works). Even without the faulty chronical ordering the idea itself is ridiculous.

Originally Posted by Abits
My point is that if we talk about Volo and dandolion, the fact that Volo is the original is completely irrelevant here. Unless Larian can do anything new or interesting with him, he will always be (at least in the context of bg3) a less cool dandolion copy. And the big thing here is that unlike Elric for example, Volo is not a super important character that you can't build a forgotten realms story without. So the decision to add him in is worthy of criticism and comparison to dandolion


Volo appears in both BG1 and Throne of Bhaal, and also provides commentary in the game manuals in the style of his "Guide to" setting guidebooks. He is also the framing device used for NwN2: Storm of Zehir. He is very much one of the most common poster boys of the setting and is still used as such by WotC.

I mean, I happen to loathe him myself. But this is hardly the first or the last work they've forced him into. He's basically the Wolverine of FR. No story needs him, nearly every story is better from him not being involved, but you'll be damned sure he's going to show up in nearly every story anyway.

I addressed the first part of your comment in literally the part you quoted but you kind of ignored that. No matter.

About Volo in BG - I played a lot of BG and I had to check the wiki to find out where can you find him in game. What I'm saying is that his roles in the early game was nothing, just a short cameo. He wasn't a character. Just a cool NPC. Bg3 did much more with him. I would claim they gave him a role similar to the one dandolion has in the Witcher - a non fighting companion that is there for humour.

Last edited by Abits; 24/11/20 09:46 AM.

Larian's Biggest Oversight, what to do about it, and My personal review of BG3 EA
"74.85% of you stood with the Tieflings, and 25.15% of you sided with Minthara. Good outweighs evil, it seems."