Some good points were made for sure.
I would argue only about that general take on companions at the end. But that's more about personal preferences plus keeping in mind that Larian intentionally gave us most "evil" companions first.
Yeah, that's true. On the other hand, there's a variation in evil, so while they're more likely to be similar than "good" characters, I don't think them being evil requires them to be this similar. I expect the rest to be similar, to be honest, judging by the one we've seen already and D:OS2.
Still holding out some hope tho.