Welp.. if it makes you feel any better... I failed a few innocent seeming rolls after entering the druids grove and kinda ended up wiping out the whole town? Only ones left standing were a handfull of kids in a cave.
Now I have to go wipe out the goblins on principle, I lost two companions, and my only chance at getting lucky is to join the absolute. I've accidentally killed off everyone!!!!
I'M A MONSTER!!!!!!!
So, depending on the crit fail, they do matter. If you let the fails fall where they may!
