Gosh this thread has sure been a read....

I'd like to add my vote to the "Elves should look less human" crowd. I know it's the wrong franchise, but I actually loved the way Elder Scrolls did their Mer (except in oblivion, but every person in that game had pudding-face disease, and you can't convince me otherwise), they have very dramatic exaggerated features that are quite distinctly not-human, and they come in a big range of non-human skin tones too.

But, failing that, if our Elves in this game are going to look more human, then I'd love for there to be more options and appearances. I'll never hate there being more choices to make characters.