Larian Studios Forums Baldur's Gate III Baldur's Gate III - General Should have given this to Obsidian

Fairly similar to how I would rank them I guess. I am not really a fan of anything science fiction or futuristic however, so in my case I would exclude Alpha Protocol, The Outer Worlds and New Vegas from the list, because I blanket dislike the genre they fall into regardless (it would also make me a really poor judge of them anyhow). Tyranny I think is the best out of the remaining ones on that list, it was criminally short however and felt like a lost opportunity for something truly great. After that, NWN 2, then between Pillars 1 and 2 I am not really sure where I would rank them. I did not enjoy the story in either game, although I liked the story in the 2nd pillars even less than the first. The combat felt a bit better in the first game, however the character building in the 2nd had a higher degree of depth. I am not sure what it was about the 2nd game, but something about the combat made everything feel super spongy. There were quite a few fights where I started becoming bored during the fight, because they dragged on and on and were just a case of repeating the same button presses over and over again.