? It's in the game that she approves of going along with Minthara's plan, and that she disapproves of betraying her (to save the grove). I agree she's not sadistic like Lae'zel and Astarion, but that doesn't really make her neutral. It's pretty mucht he basis of the alignment that to be neutral and not evil a character mustn't actively put their needs above those of others, especially if they're innocent. Because that's an evil trait.
I also don't see how guilt after doing, and supporting, something as wicked as killing a bunch of kids changes anything. Is Anakin neutral because he got manipulated and his reasons weren't all that bad? Is Thanos neutral because he eventually felt remorse about some stuff (in IW)? Not every 'evil' character is evil in the same way and for the same reasons.
At what point in the game does she approve of Mintara's plan? I literally never saw it. Tell me so I can take a look. When do you betray the Tieflings? Or when you talk to Mintara? The difference is that Thanos did it all by himself. And Shadow is a hostage to Tav's decisions, it's our decision to betray the Tieflings, not hers. So yes, she feels guilty because she didn't want to do it. And don't forget that she actually feels joy when she saves them, because she says she was worried about Tieflings. Neutral EVIL doesn't care what happens to the Tieflings, just like any other evil. Well, why should an evil character be happy about this? Weird.
upd: Well, I watched it, she doesn't approve (she just doesn't care, she doesn't react to it) of Mintara's plan, and she disapprove of her betrayal. But I think this is due to the fact that it will cause us additional problems. Not that she wants to kill the Tieflings. At the same time, Astarion (who is obviously evil), for example, does not care if we betray Mintara. So for me, it still doesn't prove that she's evil. That's not enough. Her reaction after the battle seems more important than that.
udp 2: lol sorry but she disapprove if we open gate too, she disapprove both choice with Mintara, wut means u must just kill goblins if u dont want Shadow disapprove.
