Very insightful. Thanks for taking the time to write this up.
+1
The only thing I disagree with is:
Originally Posted by Niara
it will be very poor writing if these personality traits magically flip when she gets her memories back; she's still the person that she is, after all, or should be.
People are their memories, people that lost their memories can become completely different people, losing one memories is infact akin to a spiritual death so to speak.