Originally Posted by dotmats
Quote
Fantasy stories become interesting because of differences in cultures, species, powers. If everyone is the same, then there is no discussion, no conflict and no reason to read a story, watch a movie or play a game.

I've been thinking about this too, mostly in normal life though. I'm an immigrant, so am often confronted with benefits/weaknesses of cultural differences, borders, languages etc. We're not so different from each other, but at the end of the day, if everywhere was the same, why would I have moved? At some point the twitter/ crit role/ gen z outcast crowd merges with corporate hr in a vision of equality and acceptance that is so depressingly bland one almost prefers intollerance. Where your appearance can be infinitely varied but those variations mean nothing. I can have horns and my eyes can be on fire but I still shop at Starbucks, just like you!

And in a fantasy setting, where mystery, secrets and discovery are the major escapist lures from the mundaneity of late-capitalist life, having a world of infinite races who are all pretty much the same is dull.

But that's the point: In movies/books/games, we *want* to have a conflict. Just imagine Baldur's Gate 3 without any fights. Would you play such a game?

People want to have a "zombie apocalypse", so that they have a good excuse for taking their beloved shotgun and shoot. They want to have an evil dictator or oppressive regime they can fight against for morally sound reasons. They want to have religious, ideological or ethnic conflicts.

And the question is, why would you have a problem with that in a fantasy story? After all, it's just a harmless fantasy story, a game or book? If you are truly, honestly concerned about prejudice and intolerance you can of course immediately go and protest against IS and terror attacks. But for some reason people who complain about fantasy stories and books don't ever do that?