You imply that in DoS each play through may NOT yield a different result, and that is simply not true - I played DoS games (1&2) for over 1000h, and replayed combats were different and interesting each time. And randomness in DoS is so small that it can be ignored.
Well, I am on my third playthrough - even on the first one, things get very samey very quickly. In a big part because there are only two types of abilities - one doing physical and magical damage. There isn't much beyond that. I am doing my first BG3 playthrough right now (as well as my first coop playthrough of D:OS2) and so far, BG3 is straight up improvement. That said, I didn't get deep into the game enough to experience misses. So far, most of the hits had 80-100% chances to hit, with some occasional 50-60%. Hopefully, it will get more interesting soon.
