Originally Posted by mrfuji3
Originally Posted by Scribe
Originally Posted by Dexai
It's good for power gaming, not role-playing.

That's how I've always seen the Tasha's ASI option. It's literally nothing but 'I didnt play this race before because I couldnt min/max my ASI, now I can.'
Doesn't this help both power-gaming and role-playing? If I wanted to play a goblin shaman (druid), roleplaying how I became disillusioned with goblin society, realizing that goblins that are out of balance with the world, VGtM Goblins (+2 Dex, +1 Con) punishes this. Like, okay, I could play with 14 Wis. But that will just make me less mechanically effective in game which will be less fun.

Thats pure power gaming. A role player would not care that his goblin shaman would only have 14 Wis. Rather he would see this as part of his character and role.