You keep insisting on that yet that's not something I've ever said, and it has no bearing on anything in this discussion.
Oh I didn't say you ever said that. I was just saying that these are my definitions, and according to these I can play play an Orc Wizard with 16 Intelligence or an Elf Barbarian with 17 Strength at level 1 and still be roleplaying. You said that I would then not be roleplaying, but that's because you probably use a different definition, and in that sense it was relevant to the discussion. That's fine. I'm wasn't as interested in that and moved on to what I find is a more interesting discussion.
You literally said it again in the very next few seconds. You're saying it adds to roleplaying opportunities. I am saying it is not adding to roleplaying opportunities, it is adding to powergaming opportunities. I am not saying you are not roleplaying if you play with a powergamed character. Stop with your strawmen.
