I'm hopeful we'll be able to have each character try once (for four attempts total + any inspiration dice). For Example, Tav didn't persuade to save Arabella, Gale tried and got a stern look, and then Wyll speaks up and saves Arabella. IRL some of the excitement at the table is seeing which characters succeed/fail in the skill check and how the DM can use that for future conversation between the NPC and party.
Larian can have some situations be "one-mistake-fail" (for NPCs that are stubborn) but every dialogue option being "one-mistake-fail" feels very un-D&D.
Last edited by DragonSnooz; 06/04/21 03:49 PM.
