To put the reddit post in perspective, we are talking about the views of <0.0005 of the ( assumed ) current player base.
I think a game that caters for all tastes would be better, not just one minority viewpoint or another. Promoting features that appeal to one's own preferences is normal human behaviour. Simultaneously attempting to demote features that others prefer is a less appealing trait, wherever it arises.
Multiple people using logic to form analogous opinions is not "one's own preference".
To elaborate I've seen people say they enjoy the game, but it's very rare to see someone voice the opinion that combat should stay the same. I have not seen a logically written & thought out opinion say that combat is fun as is. It's like Saito said, there is usually small degrees of disagreement on what the root cause actually is... and there are a lot of players voicing that combat needs to change.
And among those voices it's usually, "Yeah adding in more D&D 5e rules-as-written would benefit the game". That's the preference of several gamers who have played Baldur's Gate 3 and voiced their opinions on Reddit or the forums.
