Actually, not only companion, part of the story too. I feel like I am reading some random chapters from a book, and can not figure out the correct order. Every single scene itself makes sense, but together it does not form one coherent plot-line.
Example: first time protagonist sets a camp and takes the long rest, Rafael appears. And every companion suddenly acts as if we discussed in length how useful the tadpoles in our heads are. What did I miss here? Did I have to set camp earlier to get that discussion? Is there a way to trigger that discussion at least with some companions? Or may be I had to finish some side quest before that would make my protagonist re-think the danger of the tadpole?
Another source of frustration is missing random scenes, like the one where Gale explains resurrection. I saw it triggered only once, still do not know how and can not get it again. I am pretty sure there are more (I know there are more!), I just do not know how to initiate them and as a result, I miss that content.
Companions is the problem in general, though. I get that Larian is not Bioware and deep companion system is not their thing. But there are some dialogues with them, right? Could at least some of them be connected to the camp? One time during recruiting you have a chance to ask "tell me about yourself" - then nothing at all, not even "hello", only the order "I want you to stay in the camp". If this is bound to the approval rating and I somehow managed to piss off all of the companions equally, then this is still not a good system, because I am hardly unique, and it means some players would never see that part of the game (I assume, quite costly part of the game too with all voicing, animation and scripting).
Even major events are not discussable, like with Astarion and the monster hunter - there is no way to anyhow ask Astarion "what was that about?". Not only that, you can not return to monster hunter and clarify anything either. There are several lines to select during conversation, but you can choose only one. Want to know the full story - reload and choose another. Not the best option, considering loading time.
So... Does anyone know a guide that allows you to maximize dialogs count and advises on the quest order and camp-counts to make the story coherent?
