Replying to give this post more traction. I agree with the game should be closer to a more typical 5E experience. Obviously, 5e cannot be ran purely RAW as the rules require DM interpretation. My issue is most of there changes are not even typical house rules or even areas where any house rules are applied. This make the game very disjointed from Pen and Paper 5e and creates huge balance distortions with in the spells and abilities. This make transitioning way harder than it should be between the two systems.
Given they are directly partnered with WoTC, I find it strange that WoTC isn't pushing for the game to follow 5e closely. As they could create a tandem strategy between the two building players bases from each other. Additionally, they can use both as marketing campaigns for each other by release campaign modules as part or teasers for campaign books. Or even release those books as fully playable modules.
I am not commenting on your particular examples at this time. Need sleep.
D&D without the rules and themes of alignment is just a generic fantasy adventure game. 5E was already an example of taking simplification too far and diluting the interesting part of the game. BG3 is making the problem even worse, but those without any experience with the rule system will obviously not understand the consequences of these decisions. The younger audience here comes from a videogame background, and that makes sense since that is the demographic being marketed to.
I'm sure BG3 will still be a good game, but this is one area where it's a major departure from authentic D&D mechanics (which are the reason for its longevity).
It's so nice to hear from people who feel the same way. There seem to be a lot of opinions to the contrary and some validation is very welcome, so thank you both.
I know that Larian is a capable company, but I just want them to understand that D&D is more than a combat system, and covering Divinity with a D&D veneer doesn't equal a job well done. Especially with a sequel to a such a legendary franchise.
