Here, let me explain this simply since you seem to either not understand, or want to intentional misconstrue what I wrote. They are not saying they want BG3 on those forums to be strict D&D, they are saying they are glad 2 d&d BASED (I am assuming you know the difference between BASED and Replicate) games are coming out. Two different type of games to play. They are not saying they want a RAW D&D simulator just like Solasta. Hopefully that explains it to you since you want to keep trying to push this misrepresentation of what I was saying. The majority of the commenters are on that forum has the basic complaints about UI, group linking etc. Like I mentioned above, but DO NOT want a copy of Solasta mechanics.
Not to mention, I love the irony of the fact, that on the Solasta forums, they are looking forwards to BG3 (with some modifications to UI, group chain and inventory), and posters here are trying to USE Solasta as a hammer to beat BG3 with. When someone tries to post negative over analyzation of BG3, Solasta posters are defending it).
I'll entertain this for a bit.
"The irony of this is that if you go to the Solasta forums, where people try the reverse and try to start hate on BG3... the majority want and enjoy both games."
- People want both games and find ways to enjoy them, cool.
"The overall opinion is the more D&D the better, and they look forward to the differences (where here, they want a replica)."
- You didn't provide any evidence, I can't infer anything between "look forward to the differences" versus "where here, they want a replica". Without links I have to take the last two statements as a wash.
"Of course people have justifiable discussions about little things like inventory management, the ugly group chain, the UI but none of this Larian bashing or these "mechanic sux" attitude."
- Again without links or evidence it sounds like people agree on some things and disagree on others. I have to take it as a wash if you want me to buy into your anecdote. Especially since it doesn't make sense for anyone to criticize Larian on another developer's forum. Would you expect to see forum members bash EA here? Consistently?
"It is actually a pretty interesting comparison between communities."
- It's also interesting and worth discussing comparisons between Baldur's Gate 3 and Solasta (as videogames). To come full circle, it's okay to criticize Baldur's Gate 3 in early access if we get a better game on release.
