The only fact is that there are at least two camps of people ... except those who simply dont care, but i dont count them for obvious reasons. - One would like to have pure DnD experience in video game ... they kinda idealized BG-3 hoping that would be their holy grail ... bcs it was advertised
This is of course a straw man version of the argument and one that nobody actually makes.
Rather, those of us who want to see closer adherence to 5e argue that it is a better system than the mess they have in BG3 right now. Nobody is calling 5e a holy grail. Lol.
Precisely! They can even expand upon it, of course, as long as the game is fun and balanced!
I haven't seen one post saying 5e is the holy grail. Rather a lot that say rules-as-written is better than the homebrew Larian came up with.