Yeah, Menacing Attack is the best thing in the game for combat. If you land Menacing Attack with the fear effect on any enemy = GG.
It is waaaaaay past broken.
It's powerful but it hasn't been some sort of game changer for me. Some enemies seem immune, or seem to shake it off. Also I have noticed some enemies not fleeing while under the effect. Certainly the effect seems varied at least in my games. Basically I don't understand how the effect is varied and controlled. I've been able to play around with all the Battlemaster manuvers and they are all pretty powerful in different situations.
